We ARE committed to the needs of our clientele by providing a variety of insurance solutions to protect against the unexpected in life. Our agency listens to and educates our clientele and prospective clients about what insurance solutions best align with their lifestyles, the assets they have accumulated, and the everyday exposures that they face.

We’ll give you the peace of mind you deserve.



Colonial Insurance Agency, a proud member of the Professional Insurance Agents of Wisconsin, has been providing a variety of personal, business, and life insurance solutions to clients throughout Wisconsin since 1975. We represent numerous dynamic companies, allowing us to deliver the best products and prices to our customers.

While our existing clients are the foundation of our agency, we strive to serve those who are new to our agency with the same personal care and attention.

Rather than being price-driven, our insurance recommendations are value-driven.  We strive to ensure you are fully and appropriately protected without being over-protected. 

Meet the people behind Colonial Insurance Agency

The Team

Not all insurance agents are created equal. At Colonial Insurance Agency, we go out of our way to treat our clients like people and we use our industry experience and diversified knowledge base to protect what you value most in business and in life.


We have been with Don and Colonial Insurance for over 25 years. He helped us out when our driving records were not so great and found us the best rates available. He has always gotten us the best rates and made recommendations on how to get even better rates.



A well-known insurance veteran, Don has been bringing value based insurance solutions to his clients for over 45 years! His clients know him for saving them money on their insurance policies, bettering their coverage, and restoring them whole in the event of a claim. Don cherishes his role as a trusted advisor to the many friends he has the pleasure of calling his clients!

He is always happy to educate and help plan for immediate needs and as the future changes.

Besides insurance, another major passion of his is helping people. Don is active in many local charities and is a regular blood donor, offering the motto, “give a pint, have a pint (of beer)”!  

When he’s not helping to fulfill the insurance needs of his clients, you can find him spending time with his family (especially his 5 grandchildren), catching a Brewer game, or stripping fairways on the golf course!  




Born and raised in Wisconsin, Dan comes from a family that has been meeting insurance needs for over 45 years. After graduating from Menomonee Falls High School in 2008, Dan attended Edgewood College in Madison, Wisconsin. In 2012, Dan graduated from Edgewood with Bachelor of Science degree in Business and joined Colonial Insurance Agency.

Colonial Insurance Agency’s legacy is built on a foundation of service and customer retention. The 45 year retention rate from a client first working with Colonial is 97%, so once a relationship is established it remains a high priority within the agency. The agency offers personal insurance and business insurance with a focus on multifamily habitational, construction, office, retail and hospitality risk.

In his spare time, you can find Dan spending time with his two kids and wife, Samantha. He is a member of the Professional Insurance Agents of Wisconsin, Big Brothers Big Sisters and the Young Wishmakers of Wisconsin-Make A Wish Milwaukee.


Dan is one of the most knowledgeable insurance agents around! Ask him about coverages, home or auto, you name it... he knows how to best protect you and your family!


I had a run of bad luck one year with 2 accidents and then later a roof repair. Jack came through! Everything was handled and fixed quickly to my satisfaction. Outstanding company!

Personal & Commercial Insurance Advisor

Jack Larsen

Jack is a Menomonee Falls native, graduating from UW-Whitewater with a degree in Management and Economics. Jack brings 9 years of experience working with a fortune 50 company in Leadership and Assets Protection. He is a valuable resource to support with risk mitigation while providing both personal and commercial insurance.

In his spare time, you can find Jack venturing in the woods; whether that’s looking for his golf ball or enjoying the countryside land in Waupaca. 




Julie has been advising Colonial’s clients for over 20 years. As a licensed agent there isn’t a question or scenario that Julie hasn’t come across. If you need help updating your policy, filing a claim, or just great advice, Julie is your person. In her spare time you’ll find Julie spending time with her family and grandkids.


Our agency is proud to represent some of the most reputable insurance carriers in the industry.

"We are much more than insurance, we are home."


Colonial Insurance Agency is independently owned and locally operated to handle your insurance needs. Our role is to serve as a trusted advisor. We will consult with you to help you understand your needs before recommending the best combination of coverage, service, and value for your unique situation.


We strive to form a personalized policy for each client by using multiple insurance providers to create the best fit for each person. We won’t simply sell you a product—we will be a resource you can count on to look out for your best interests.