We do more than cover you
- we care for you.

Get the level of attention and understanding that you deserve.



Colonial Insurance Agency is committed to improving the quality of our community by insuring your life’s hard work. Setting a standard of excellence, our professional staff will help you understand your current and future risk exposures by building a lifelong relationship. Our clients can be confident in the organization’s proven stability. 

We are dedicated to continuous improvement through the use of technology in order to provide the most comprehensive and cost effective solutions. We are here to help!

Colonial Insurance Coverage

Home Insurance

Your home is more than a structure - it is an investment in your family. Protect it well.

Auto Insurance

Find the right kinds of coverage and protection you need for all the things that drive you.

Umbrella Insurance

Extra coverage to financially protect you and your family from the unforeseen.

Life Insurance

Whatever your unique life insurance needs, we've got you covered.

Business Insurance

Although there may be risks in the business world, we can help you manage those risks.

Why put your trust in our insurance agency?

When you need to purchase an insurance policy, get in touch with Colonial Insurance Agency. We’re committed to helping you find the best coverage available that’s still within your budget. You should choose our insurance agency because we’re:

Client-focused. We go above and beyond to find the best insurance rates for our clients.

Attentive. We know that insurance policies aren’t one-size-fits-all, which is why we take the time to figure out your exact wants and needs.

Knowledgeable. We can answer all of your questions about different types of insurance coverage.

We’re located off of Main Street in Menomonee Falls. Make an appointment with us today!


Our agency is proud to represent some of the most reputable insurance carriers in the industry.

We were exceptionally happy with the service we received after talking with Dan. Not only do we feel we got the best rates, he was friendly professional and made us feel well taken care of. Thanks Dan!


My family has used Colonial Insurance for over 20 years for everything. We always feel well informed on the products offered and are able to make a decision easily with their help. I highly recommend Colonial Insurance for anyone with insurance needs!


I have all my business and personal insurance with Colonial Insurance. They are amazing! Whenever we have needed them, they have been available and accommodating. The best bunch of people you will ever work with!